MLB CONSENSUS PICKS
What are the MLB Consensus Picks?
May 5th
| Moneyline | Total | Runline | |
|---|---|---|---|
 909 Giants Webb (R) | 3 | 2 | 0 |
 910 Phillies Walker (R) | 5 | 0 | 0 |
| 8 Handicapper Picks | 2 Handicapper Picks | | |
| Open | -122 | o8 | SF -1.5 |
| Consensus | -110 | o8 | SF -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 901 Rockies · 3 Feltner (R) | 0 | 1 | 0 |
 902 Pirates · 5 Falter (L) | 0 | 2 | 0 |
| | 3 Handicapper Picks Consensus: L | | |
| Open | -148 | o8.5 | PIT -1.5 |
| Consensus | -162 | o7 | PIT -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 911 Tigers · 2 Skubal (L) | 1 | 0 | 0 |
 912 Yankees · 5 Cortes (L) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 1 Handicapper Pick Consensus: L | | | |
| Open | -126 | o7 | NYY -1.5 |
| Consensus | -132 | o6.5 | NYY -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 923 Mets · 6 Severino (R) | 2 | 1 | 0 |
 924 Rays · 7 Pepiot (R) | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 3 Handicapper Picks Consensus: L | 1 Handicapper Pick Consensus: W | | |
| Open | -122 | o7.5 | TB -1.5 |
| Consensus | -108 | o7 | NYM -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 913 Angels · 1 Canning (R) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
 914 Guardians · 4 Carrasco (R) | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| 2 Handicapper Picks Consensus: W | | | |
| Open | -134 | o8.5 | CLE -1.5 |
| Consensus | -154 | o8 | CLE -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 915 Rangers · 3 Gray (R) | 2 | 0 | 0 |
 916 Royals · 2 Lynch IV (L) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 2 Handicapper Picks Consensus: W | | | |
| Open | -132 | o8.5 | TEX -1.5 |
| Consensus | -138 | o8.5 | TEX -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 917 Mariners · 5 Miller (R) | 2 | 0 | 0 |
 918 Astros · 4 Brown (R) | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 3 Handicapper Picks Consensus: W | | | |
| Open | -126 | o8.5 | HOU -1.5 |
| Consensus | -132 | o8.5 | HOU -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 919 Red Sox · 9 Criswell (R) | 0 | 1 | 0 |
 920 Twins · 2 Ryan (R) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| | 1 Handicapper Pick Consensus: W | | |
| Open | -162 | o8 | MIN -1.5 |
| Consensus | -184 | o7.5 | MIN -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 925 White Sox · 5 Crochet (L) | 1 | 0 | 0 |
 926 Cardinals · 1 Liberatore (L) | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2 Handicapper Picks Consensus: P | | | |
| Open | -180 | o7.5 | STL -1.5 |
| Consensus | -162 | o7.5 | STL -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 903 Brewers · 0 Peralta (R) | 2 | 0 | 0 |
 904 Cubs · 5 Assad (R) | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| 4 Handicapper Picks Consensus: P | | | |
| Open | -132 | o8.5 | CHC -1.5 |
| Consensus | -136 | o6.5 | MIL -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 927 Marlins · 12 Sanchez (R) | 1 | 1 | 0 |
 928 Athletics · 3 Boyle (R) | 2 | 0 | 1 |
| 3 Handicapper Picks Consensus: L | 1 Handicapper Pick Consensus: W | 1 Handicapper Pick Consensus: L | |
| Open | -116 | o7.5 | MIA -1.5 |
| Consensus | -134 | o7.5 | OAK -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 929 Orioles · 11 Kremer (R) | 2 | 0 | 0 |
 930 Reds · 1 Lodolo (L) | 4 | 1 | 0 |
| 6 Handicapper Picks Consensus: L | 1 Handicapper Pick Consensus: L | | |
| Open | -112 | o9.5 | BAL -1.5 |
| Consensus | -130 | o9 | CIN -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 905 Braves · 1 Fried (L) | 4 | 0 | 0 |
 906 Dodgers · 5 Paxton (L) | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 5 Handicapper Picks Consensus: L | | | |
| Open | -124 | o9 | ATL -1.5 |
| Consensus | -154 | o8.5 | ATL -1.5 |
| Final | Moneyline | Total | Runline |
 907 Padres · 4 Waldron (R) | 1 | 0 | 0 |
 908 Diamondbacks · 11 Nelson (R) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 1 Handicapper Pick Consensus: L | | | |
| Open | -110 | o10 | SD -1.5 |
| Consensus | -112 | o8.5 | SD -1.5 |
MLB Consensus Picks
If you’re looking for top rated picks from all of our MLB expert handicappers, then our MLB Consensus Picks report is the product for you. The latest product offering provides an aggregate number of selections on the three most popular betting markets from our MLB expert handicappers on all available games.
The Consensus report will be updated daily and will feature selections on the three most popular pre-game MLB betting markets - Moneyline, Total (Over-Under) and Run Line.
Click on each of the “Market Tabs” to view all of the available picks for each game.
The report is updated as selections are posted and as a courtesy to our loyal users, the MLB Consensus Picks report will provide a free matchup and percentages to view daily.
Another great feature of this product is the ability to track and view ALL selections from our MLB experts by viewing the MLB Consensus Picks report records from the previous days and throughout the season.
Unlock the MLB Consensus Picks report below and start following all the top selections today!
What are the MLB Consensus Picks?
The MLB Consensus Picks are a detailed report that provides a breakdown of selections for each matchup based on the three most popular pre-game betting markets for MLB bettors: Moneyline, Total (Over-Under) and Run Line. For each of these betting markets, the MLB Consensus shows a percentage breakdown and the total number of selections made on each matchup. These numbers are a great handicapping tool as bettors can see a quick snapshot in which way bettors are leaning on a moneyline, total or run line wager.
Our MLB Matchups offer a more comprehensive betting trends percentage breakdown from the action that operators are receiving on specific games. Knowing the betting public plays through these operators, the majority of the leans usually trend toward favorites with moneyline wagers and the over in total bets.
For the MLB Consensus Picks at VegasInsider, the data is showing all available selections made by our MLB expert handicappers. Unlike the majority of bettors, our MLB expert handicappers have a great pulse on the diamond and rest assured, we also track and show that experience with our leaderboards and documented records.
Understanding the MLB Consensus Picks
The VegasInsider MLB Consensus Picks provide betting percentages on three different markets and the point-spread is the most popular. In the below example of the MLB matchup between Seattle and Houston, there are a total of seven selections posted on the three markets from our MLB experts.
Moneyline: 7
Total: 1
Run Line: 1
The moneyline betting market had seven handicapper picks and all two were on the Mariners and five were on the Astros, therefore 71% of the consensus was on Houston for this matchup. The total or over-under market also had one pick on the ‘over’ or high side. The Run Line only had 1 handicapper pick posted and it was on Seattle, which was a 1-0 lean or 100% on the Mariners +1.5 on the run line wager.
MLB Consensus Picks Record
What differentiates the MLB Consensus Picks at VegasInsider is our presentation of the records based on previous day trends. Users can toggle between previous days or weeks and check out how profitable the MLB Consensus Picks fared. The overall Consensus Picks Record grades each matchup and betting market that had selections posted. The three grades are Win, Loss and Push. We identify a Push as a tie and in the case of our MLB Consensus Picks, that would be identified as a 50-50% split.
In the above example, the Los Angeles Dodgers defeated the San Diego Padres 5-3 and there were ten handicapper picks on this matchup. The Moneyline was a Loss since the Padres lost the game, while the Total was a Win with the ‘over’ cashing and the Run Line was a Win since the Dodgers (-1.5) won by two runs.
Fading or Following the MLB Consensus Picks
The MLB Consensus Picks are a great handicapping tool for bettors with different styles. Some users like to go against the grain and play the opposite of the betting public and those individuals are often referred to as ‘contrarian’ bettors. The bettors that often side with the higher percentages in each matchup would be defined as ‘chalky’ players. Some might scoff at that term knowing that the favorites do cash more often than not on the MLB diamond.
Our advice is to take a look at our MLB Consensus Picks and then compare them to the data in the MLB Matchups index. If you tend to see a large following of VegasInsider experts on an underdog or under wager and the betting public on the opposite sides, then it’s probably a great idea to back our group instead of the general consensus.
Don't start betting on the MLB without the added boost of the BetMGM bonus code. Use VIBONUS1600 during sign-up to get an awesome welcome bonus when following the MLB Consensus Picks: Exclusive Offer: Get a 20% Deposit Match up to $1,600 in Sports Bonus!.
MLB Consensus Picks Frequently Asked Questions
What is the MLB consensus?
The MLB consensus tells you what percentage of the betting public are taking on a side of a given bet. This is a great way to see where the public is betting, and if you want to "fade" the public by going with the less-popular choice.
Should I follow the MLB Consensus to the letter?
You should not always follow consensus picks. They typically fall to whatever side a bettor is familiar with and could end up being skewed due to that. It's always a good thing to know what side the public is betting, but important as well is doing your own research and picking a side based on that.
What is a consensus pick?
A consensus pick is a betting pick that goes with the public opinion.
Can MLB consensus picks be trusted?
It is always much smarter to trust an industry consensus pick page over an unlicensed page that could be skewed in a certain way. Our consensus page allows you to check odds from a variety of sources.
